Ray LaMontagne ‘Trouble’
Dave Matthews Band ‘The Space Between’
It’s not that I can’t live without him. I just don’t want to she said. She felt ridiculous, dramatic, and judging by his reaction, vindicated. It was nothing short of heart wrenching, watching him walk away. Not that she didn’t love Boy B, but Boy A was in such a state. She had shared drinks and laughs, saliva and long hours without sleep. She’d shed so many tears and even if though she’d used up his share of emotional distress and then some, there was a soft spot hidden somewhere that resurfaced at that instant and made her whisper wait.
She remembered Boy A all at once then, with a tainted fondness. It’s like watching a silent movie in your head she thought; in silence, with poor quality and with all the actions of the characters put on fast forward…It made sense how recalling him speak she realized nothing really came out of his mouth. Even though it wasn’t her fault, and not only Boy A but the rest of the goddamn world had told her, she guessed her real attachment to the whole sordid and shameful situation came down to one thing: it was the only thing she’d ever really failed at.
She made good grades in school, had a good job, a great guy…now (finally). She ended up on top of, well, maybe not on top, but at least on the surface of the pile of shit we all call life. She had succeeded in overcoming all her obstacles save one. Save him. Someone had to, and for the longest time she thought it had to be her. She knew what it was like to be abandoned, and she swore she wouldn’t turn her back on Boy A.
It was that first night, watching him crack a wry, sideways smile and flick his cigarette. She felt lucky, special, aware of his awkward confidence and odd charisma. No one else seemed to notice, but she discovered a gem and found it priceless from the start. It was included, common, without sparkle, but she hadn’t see that, not quite yet.
She reveled, giddy and glad to be out in crisp spring morning air, goofing off, and with him. The old leaves that’d survived winter heaped up around her, stuck in her hair and sweater and she squinted at the camera. Snap. It was the only shot he ever took of her, and consequently, but mirrored of the situation, it didn’t turn out well. For the meantime, she savoured a four-day weekend with him, and without going home between. There were a few more drinks, and many laughs. Most of them stilted, conversation let out in small intervals as if on tenuous terms and of a delicate nature. It was something she could never quite put her finger on–why couldn’t she be completely herself? It wasn’t until later that all the walking on eggshells was simple insecurity. Even when he gazed at her as though the world had stopped, glassy eyed and gentle, she was most suppressed and aware she was not his, and he that he was certainly not hers.
“I wonder if I’ve been changed in the night? Let me think. Was I the same when I got up this morning? I almost think I can remember feeling a little different. But if I’m not the same, the next question is ‘Who in the world am I?’ Ah, that’s the great puzzle!“
There was nothing different about her. The tide had turned, and it was, consequently, red tide. Everything was dead. She knew better than to go back, so she took cover alone and stayed far from the poison. A safer, high tide reached back out to her and she was swept away.
She drowned. That is all. Now back from the silent movie of an awkward stint of life with him. Reality. She told him no more. He was walking away. Yes, perfect. She whispered wait, and watching him stop, hope in his eyes, ready to run back to her with more apologies, more lies, kisses, whatever it took. It was her cue. She turned her back on him and let him crumble alone and confused. It was wrong, and hurt her to hurt anyone else, but it was right, in a vengeful, Old Testament way. Now he knew just how she had felt. It took almost two years, and not the usual two months for someone to walk away, and though he beat her to the punch the first time, he was hers for once he swore and she cared more for herself.
She still hated the way she’d been, used up, squeezed out to the very end, but there was a redemption waiting.